What is Methodologies of Fashion Critique?

 

Methodologies of fashion critique refer to the different approaches and methods that can be used to analyze and evaluate fashion. There is no one right way to critique fashion, and different critics may use different methodologies depending on their specific goals and interests. However, there are some common methodologies that are used in fashion critique, including:

Formal analysis: This methodology focuses on the aesthetic elements of fashion, such as the design, construction, and materials used in a garment. Critics using this methodology may examine the garment's silhouette, drape, color, and pattern, as well as the quality of the workmanship.

Social and cultural analysis: This methodology examines fashion in relation to the social and cultural context in which it is produced and consumed. Critics using this methodology may consider factors such as the garment's target audience, the designer's background and motivations, and the broader social and cultural trends that are reflected in the garment.

Historical analysis: This methodology examines fashion in relation to its historical context. Critics using this methodology may consider factors such as the garment's style, construction, and materials, as well as the social and cultural context in which it was worn.

Theoretical analysis: This methodology uses theoretical frameworks from other disciplines, such as sociology, anthropology, and art history, to analyze fashion. Critics using this methodology may examine fashion in relation to concepts such as identity, representation, and power.

In addition to these general methodologies, there are also a number of more specific approaches to fashion critique. For example, some critics may focus on specific aspects of fashion, such as sustainability, ethics, or diversity. Other critics may focus on particular fashion designers, brands, or trends.

The methodology that a critic chooses will depend on a number of factors, including their own expertise and interests, the goals of their critique, and the specific fashion items or trends that they are analyzing.

Here are some examples of how different methodologies might be used in fashion critique:

A critic using a formal analysis methodology might write a review of a new collection from a fashion designer, examining the design, construction, and materials used in the garments.

A critic using a social and cultural analysis methodology might write an essay about the representation of gender in fashion advertising.

A critic using a historical analysis methodology might write a book about the evolution of the wedding dress over time.

A critic using a theoretical analysis methodology might write an article about the relationship between fashion and identity in the digital age.

Fashion critique can be a valuable tool for understanding and appreciating fashion, as well as for challenging the status quo and promoting social change. By using different methodologies, fashion critics can offer a variety of perspectives on fashion and its role in society.

Is there a designer who doesn't appreciate fashion criticism?

There are a few designers who have expressed their dislike of fashion criticism. For example, in a 2022 interview with Fashionista, Christian Cowan said that he "personally no longer reads reviews, mainly because I just want to stay on my creative journey and do what I do." He explained that he used to read reviews early in his career, and that a good review would make him elated.

Another designer who has spoken out against fashion criticism is Kanye West. In a 2015 interview with The New York Times, West said that he believes fashion critics are "outdated" and that they "don't get it." He explained that he sees his own fashion designs as art, and that he doesn't need the approval of critics to know that his work is good.

While some designers may not appreciate fashion criticism, it is important to note that fashion critics play an important role in the industry. They help to shape public opinion and identify emerging trends. They also provide feedback to designers, which can help them to improve their work.

It is also important to note that fashion criticism is not always negative. In fact, many critics write positive reviews of fashion shows and collections. However, it is inevitable that some critics will have negative things to say about certain designers' work. This is simply part of the creative process.

Ultimately, it is up to each individual designer to decide how they want to react to fashion criticism. Some designers may choose to ignore it, while others may choose to engage with it. It is also important to remember that fashion criticism is just one perspective, and that there is no such thing as a universally agreed-upon "good" or "bad" design.

Is fashion photography an instrument of critique?

Yes, fashion photography can be used as an instrument of critique. Fashion photography is not just about capturing beautiful images of clothes and models. It can also be used to make statements about social, cultural, and political issues

For example, fashion photography has been used to critique gender roles, body image, and racial stereotypes. It has also been used to promote diversity and inclusion in the fashion industry.

Here are some examples of fashion photography that has been used as an instrument of critique:

In 2017, photographer Annie Leibovitz shot a series of portraits of famous women for Vanity Fair. The portraits were inspired by the Last Supper painting by Leonardo da Vinci, and they featured women such as Serena Williams, Jane Fonda, and Nicole Kidman. The series was praised for its powerful representation of women from different backgrounds and walks of life.

In 2018, photographer Tyler Mitchell photographed Beyoncé for the cover of Vogue magazine. Mitchell was the first black photographer to shoot a cover for Vogue, and the photo was seen as a significant moment for the fashion industry.

In 2020, photographer Quil Lemons shot a series of portraits of Black Lives Matter activists for The New York Times Magazine. The portraits were praised for their sensitive and respectful portrayal of the activists.